Monthly Archives: December 2012

How Do I Make My Chapter 13 Plan Payments?

By Ryan C. Wood

You are responsible for making your Chapter 13 plan payments on time every month once your Chapter 13 bankruptcy case is filed. You will receive a notice from the trustee’s office in the mail detailing when the first payment is due and how to make the payment. Most bankruptcy lawyers also send you the same information at the time your case is filed. The Chapter 13 trustee that is assigned to your bankruptcy case will be providing you with information on when and where to make your Chapter 13 plan payments. The trustee can and will file a motion to dismiss your case if you fail to make these monthly payments. Some trustees are more lenient than others when it comes to filing a motion to dismiss for nonpayment. Some trustees will file the motion immediately after a missed payment and some trustees will wait until you are a month or more behind before filing a motion to dismiss for nonpayment. However, you should always be aware of how much you owe and when you have made a payment. You cannot rely on the trustee to tell you that you are late on a payment because that may be too late to save your Chapter 13 bankruptcy case from dismissal.

There are several ways to make a plan payment to your Chapter 13 trustee. One way is to have the plan payments be directly deducted out of your paycheck. This way ensures that your plan payments will always be made on time. However, some people just do not like seeing their paychecks decreased for any reason and like to make the payments themselves. That is fine as well. You can personally mail in the payment to the trustee every month. Most trustees require that you pay with cashier’s check or money order only. They do not want to deal with bounced checks. You should keep copies of all payments that you have made so that if there are any errors in accounting you can provide proof of payment. What happens if you mailed your payment into the trustee but the trustee never received your payment? Unfortunately, having your payment lost in the mail is one of the possibilities and risks of mailing in a payment. If the trustee indicates that he or she never received your payment you can look into canceling the cashier’s check or money order that was not received and obtaining a new one to mail to the trustee immediately. One method of ensuring that you know exactly where your payment is would be to purchase a delivery confirmation or some other way of tracking the mail. However, that may be costly and adds up over time. The choice is entirely up to you. Not all trustees have set up or approved paying by ACH, but a third way of making a payment that is becoming more common is to pay the trustee electronically through your checking account. Most trustees do not take regular “bill pay” from your bank since it is similar to a personal check: it could bounce and would be a headache to resolve and would also result in lots of fees that you would need to pay. The electronic payment would most likely be from a third party vendor approved by the trustee that you would need to go through. There are costs involved but it would probably save you a lot of time and would be convenient so you would need to weigh the convenience factor against the cost.

If you are not able to make a payment because of changed financial circumstances you should contact your bankruptcy lawyer immediately to modify your Chapter 13 plan. Do not wait until it is too late before contacting your attorney. If you do not have an attorney you should modify your plan yourself once you know that there will be changed circumstances such as being on disability, less work hours, or being laid off. There are a lot of different ways in which your financial circumstances could change. If you are planning on filing a Chapter 13 it is highly recommended that you seek the services of an experienced attorney to help you through your Chapter 13 bankruptcy case.

Does My Non-Filing Spouse Need to Provide Pay Stubs in My Bankruptcy Case? Yes You Are Married

By Ryan C. Wood

Just because you need to file for bankruptcy does not mean that your spouse will need to file as well or has to file as well.  There may be many reasons why only one spouse chooses to file for bankruptcy protection. Maybe your spouse does not have any significant debts to warrant filing for bankruptcy, or your spouse has good credit and does not want to have bankruptcy on his or her credit report.  Possibly your spouse does not qualify to receive a bankruptcy discharge due to some circumstance.  Bottom line is your spouse is not required to file for bankruptcy no matter what the reason is. However, just because your spouse is not filing for bankruptcy with you does not mean your spouse does not have any obligations in your bankruptcy case to cooperate and properly disclose their income, expenses and assets (both community and separate property assets.)  Only community assets are part of the bankruptcy estate created upon the filing of the bankruptcy petition though.

You Are Married And That Creates One Community

Many spouses have the mistaken belief that since they are not filing for bankruptcy they should not be involved in the bankruptcy case in any aspect, but that is not true.  As much as you may want to ignore you are legally married you cannot ignore it in a legal proceeding like filing for bankruptcy protection that you are in fact married.  Like it or not California law once you are married forces some presumptions on you as a spouse.  California community property law assumes both you and your spouse have command and control over the community income, expenses and assets.  Both spouses are liable for community debts; that is debts incurred during marriage whether regardless of which spouse entered into or signed the contract.  You are married.  There is only one community.  I know, I know that you have separate bank accounts and do not know how much your spouses earns each but you are married.  It does not matter how you conduct your business in the real world because you are married.  It is no ones business and you are free to you how you so choose.  You are now seeking to discharge your debts by filing for bankruptcy protection and we have certain obligations that must be done correctly.

Your spouse will still need to provide pay stubs for the 6-month period right before your bankruptcy case is filed and cooperate with your bankruptcy attorney. Your spouse’s pay stubs and yours are needed for purposes of calculating your average household income for the 6-month period on the Means Test or Chapter 13 Statement of Monthly Disposable Income. This means if you file your case in December, you will need to provide you and your spouse’s pay stubs from June to November to complete the 6-month period.  Something that I run into time and time again is You need to reassure your spouse that just because he or she is providing pay stubs in your bankruptcy case does not mean that he or she is filing for bankruptcy with you. Your spouse’s credit will not be affected by your bankruptcy filing by providing the necessary pay stubs.

Another requirement is that your bankruptcy lawyer must provide 60 days of pay stubs to the trustee prior to the meeting of creditors. This consists of the 60 day period prior to your bankruptcy filing. Some jurisdictions require the 60 day pay stubs to be filed with the court and some jurisdictions only require the 60 day pay stubs to be provided to your trustee directly. Whether or not your spouse’s pay stubs need to be provided to the trustee will depend on the local rules of your jurisdiction. When in doubt you can always contact your trustee and ask whether your spouse’s pay stubs are required. If you have a bankruptcy attorney, your attorney will be able to answer your questions and your attorney will be able to provide the required documents to the trustee (assuming you provided all the requested documentation to your attorney, of course).

You are married.  You are married.  When I ask you something and you say I do not know or why does that matter my answer will be your married.